Philip Flavio

1846-1859

William Eaton

1859-1866

H.A. Sabatzky

1867-1868

H.G. Gilmore

March 1868-Fall 1868

William B. Schulze

October 1868-1874

J. Ernest Perring

1874-1876

James Kirkland

1876-1883

(organist, then director)

Emile Levy (organist)

1879?-1882

H.E. Piano

1883

Christopher Philip Winkler

?

Charles W. Wright

?

Nettie L. (Elizabeth) Musser

?-1896

R. Jefferson Hall

1896-1911

(organized first choir)

Gaston Otey Wilkins

1911-1912

Walter W. Boutelle

1912

Adolph Steuterman

1912-1914

(organist)

Gail H. Browne

1912-1914

(choir director)

Birdie Chamberlain

1914-1919

(organist)

Ben H. Carr

1914-1919

(choir director)

Adolph Steuterman

1919-1972

John Hooker

1972-1986

David Kienzle

1987-1993

John Wright

1993-1999

Thomas Pavlechko

2000-2006

Sumner Jenkins

2006-